New Jersey’s Ultimate Meatball Guide: The Top 5 Spots

Here are the five best meatballs in New Jersey, according to reviews from Italian foodies on a major website.

If you’re a restaurant that makes the best meatballs in New Jersey, then you’re truly among the elite of the elite.

Who has the best meatballs in New Jersey?

We looked on Yelp to see which Garden State restaurants have the best meatballs in the state.

The top five restaurants in this category according to this website are all fantastic places and each deserves a spot on your bucket list.

Here’s the ultimate guide to New Jersey meatballs. We have made it our mission to weed out all restaurants outside of New Jersey.

Here are the best restaurants in New Jersey for meatballs

#5 Your sister’s balls, Colts Neck. In our opinion, possibly the biggest Italian restaurant name ever. They are located in Colts Neck.

#4 Grandma’s Meatballs, Manasquan. With a name like that, the meatballs must be great. They are located at 109 Route 71 in Manasquan.

Read more: The Best Italian Restaurants in New Jersey

#3 Angelo’s Trattoria, Bordentown. A pasta and meatball lover’s paradise, it’s located at 218 Farnsworth Ave. in Bordentown.

#2 Mama’s Meatballs, Pennsauken. If you liked the name “Grandma’s Meatballs” at #5, you must also love “Mama’s Meatballs.”

No. 1 Lucas Ristorante, Somerset. They have everything from lunch and dinner to delicious pizza and of course their award winning meatballs. They are located at Route 27 2019 in Somerset.

These are all great options, but I have to add my favorite meatball restaurant in New Jersey as an honorable mention.

I suggest adding an amazing family restaurant in Point Pleasant with meatballs that all our mothers would be proud of.

Also try Graziano’s Italian Restaurant on Route 88 in Point Pleasant. You won’t regret it.